top of page
Writer's pictureBenjamin Mares

Catch 'Em All: The Essential Pokémon Base Set Buying Guide

Updated: Aug 7

The Pokémon Base Set is where it all began, a nostalgic goldmine for collectors and a cornerstone of any serious Pokémon card collection. Released in 1999, this set introduced the world to the original 151 Pokémon and ignited a collecting frenzy that continues to this day. Whether you’re a seasoned collector or a newcomer, this guide will help you navigate the complexities of the Base Set, focusing on the hottest cards, understanding the differences between editions, and identifying key variations like shadowless cards.


The Hottest Cards in the Base Set: Holofoils


When it comes to the Base Set, holofoil cards are the crown jewels. These cards feature a shiny, holographic background that makes them stand out. However, not all holos are created equally. To help you navigate the Base Set’s holographic offerings, we’ve categorized them into tiers based on their popularity, rarity, and market value.

The Big Three

Unlimited Base Set Charizard
  • Charizard – The most iconic card in the Pokémon TCG, Charizard is the holy grail of the Base Set. Its combination of power, design, and nostalgia makes it the most sought-after and valuable holo in the set.

  • Blastoise – As the final evolution of Squirtle, Blastoise is another fan-favorite. Its powerful presence and enduring popularity place it firmly in the top tier of Base Set holos.

  • Venusaur – Completing the trio of original starter evolutions, Venusaur is highly coveted by collectors aiming to secure all three. Its rarity and connection to the starter Pokémon make it a prized card.


Legendary Powerhouses


Unlimited Base Set Mewtwo
  • Mewtwo – Known as one of the most powerful Pokémon, Mewtwo’s holofoil card is a must-have for collectors. Its mystique and in-game power translate into high demand among enthusiasts.

  • Zapdos – As one of the three Legendary Birds, Zapdos holds a special place in many collections. Its striking design and rarity make it a highly desirable card.

  • Alakazam – Renowned for its Psychic abilities, Alakazam is a popular choice among collectors. Its holofoil version is particularly prized for its unique artwork and in-game strength.


Fan Favorites

Unlimited Base Set Raichu
  • Gyarados – Known for its ferocious design and powerful attacks, Gyarados is a fan favorite. Its holofoil card is always in demand, making it a solid mid-tier collectible.

  • Raichu – As Pikachu’s evolved form, Raichu benefits from the franchise’s mascot status. Its holofoil version is beloved by fans and is a staple of many collections.

  • Machamp – Machamp is unique in that its holofoil version was included in every Base Set Starter Deck, but First Edition versions are still highly prized. Its iconic four-armed design makes it a standout card.

  • Nidoking – This powerful Poison/Ground-type Pokémon has a dedicated following, and its holofoil card is a favorite among collectors who appreciate its unique design and strength.


Underrated Gems


  • Chansey – Known for its high HP and supportive role in the games, Chansey’s holofoil card is often overlooked but remains a valuable piece, especially in mint condition.

Unlimited Base Set Ninetales
  • Poliwrath – While not as iconic as some of the others, Poliwrath’s holofoil card is a hidden gem, appreciated by collectors who value its distinct look and water-type abilities.

  • Magneton – Magneton’s holofoil card is often underrated, but its striking design and rarity make it a sleeper hit among Base Set collectors.

  • Hitmonchan – Hitmonchan’s holofoil card is a nod to fans of fighting-type Pokémon. Its design and relative scarcity make it a cherished card for those who appreciate the underdogs of the set.

  • Clefairy – While Clefairy may not be the most powerful Pokémon, its holofoil card has a charm that resonates with collectors who value the more whimsical side of the Pokémon world.

  • Ninetales – With its elegant design and fire-type allure, Ninetales is an underrated yet beautiful addition to any Base Set holofoil collection. These tiers can help guide your collecting journey, whether you're aiming to complete the entire set or focusing on the most iconic and valuable cards. Remember, each holofoil card has its own unique appeal, and building a collection is about finding what resonates with you.


First Edition vs. Unlimited: What’s the Difference?


Understanding the difference between First Edition and Unlimited cards is crucial for any collector:

First Edition Base Set Charizard
  • First Edition: These cards were part of the initial print run and can be identified by a small “Edition 1” stamp located slightly below and to the left of the Pokémon illustration. First Edition cards are significantly rarer and more valuable, making them a top priority for serious collectors.

  • Unlimited Edition: After the First Edition print run, the Unlimited Edition cards were released without the “Edition 1” stamp. While these cards are still valuable, they are more common and generally fetch lower prices than their First Edition counterparts.


Shadowless Cards: Identifying the Rare Variant


In the original Base Set, 1st Edition cards were printed first, featuring a distinct 1st Edition stamp and a "shadowless" design, meaning the card image had no drop shadow, giving it a unique look. Machamp, however, was the only 1st Edition card that appeared in both shadowless and shadowed versions in this set. After the initial run, the 1st Edition stamp was removed, but the shadowless design remained for a while. These cards, identical to the 1st Edition but without the stamp, are what we call "Shadowless." Later, to enhance the card's visual appeal, the design was updated by adding a shadow behind the card image and making the HP and attack texts bolder. These updated versions are known as "Unlimited."


Key identifiers for Shadowless cards include:


  • No Drop Shadow: As the name suggests, these cards lack the shadow around the box that surrounds the Pokémon’s image.

  • Thinner HP Font: The font used for the Pokémon’s HP is thinner on Shadowless cards compared to later prints.

  • Card Year: Shadowless cards have the year “1999” printed twice on the bottom with it being listed on the bottom "1995, 96, 98, 99" and then again "1999 Wizards"

Base Set Unlimited vs Shadowless Charizard

Shadowless cards are more valuable than Unlimited cards but generally less valuable than First Edition cards.


Tips for Buying Pokémon Base Set Cards


When buying Pokémon Base Set cards, especially online, it’s important to keep a few things in mind:


  • Condition Matters: The condition of a card is paramount. Cards are graded on a scale from 1 to 10, with 10 being gem mint. Always check the card’s condition closely, looking for any scratches, bends, or whitening on the edges.

  • Authentication: Given the value of these cards, fakes are common. Ensure you’re buying from reputable sellers and consider getting high-value cards authenticated by a professional grading service like PSA or Beckett.

  • Price Research: Familiarize yourself with the current market prices for the cards you’re interested in. Websites like TCG Player and eBay’s completed listings can give you a good sense of what you should be paying. Remember, for many cards there are 2-3 different variations, which will sometimes drastically change the value of the card.


Conclusion: Building Your Pokémon Base Set Collection


Whether you’re reliving childhood memories or starting a new collecting journey, the Pokémon Base Set offers a unique opportunity to own a piece of trading card history. By understanding the nuances of the set—like the differences between First Edition, Unlimited, and Shadowless cards—you can make informed decisions and build a collection that’s both valuable and deeply satisfying.

Pokemon Base Set Holos

Remember, the thrill of collecting is as much about the journey as it is about the destination. So, happy hunting, and may your pulls be holofoil!

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


bottom of page